Clarence Darrow – People v. State https://www.peoplevstate.com fairly undermining public confidence in the administration of justice Mon, 14 Nov 2011 02:58:58 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.4.15 Dershowitz on the Darwin Darrow Defended https://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1431 https://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1431#respond Wed, 09 Nov 2011 20:20:57 +0000 http://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1431 Check out this eye-opening essay by Alan Dershowitz (H/T Evolution News & Views) at the website of a new movie about the Scopes Monkey Trial, “alleged,” starring Brian Dennehy as Clarence Darrow and Fred Thompson as William Jennings Bryan. As Dershowitz shows, the textbook from which John Scopes was accused of teaching, Hunter’s Civic Biology, was replete with racism and eugenic advocacy.

On a related note, Jeff Gamso credits Mike at Crime & Federalism with having the best tag line in the whole blogosphere:

Because everything I was ever told was a lie.

]]>
https://www.peoplevstate.com/?feed=rss2&p=1431 0
Darrow “often used my poems to rescue his clients from the electric chair.” https://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1298 https://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1298#comments Mon, 10 Oct 2011 05:28:52 +0000 http://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1298 Noted A. E. Housman, whom Darrow visited in 1927. Housman has long been a personal favorite of mine, ever since I was turned on to him (and Omar, and Reading Gaol) by Robert Service’s poem “Bookshelf.” Here’s a representative sample:

Stars, I have seen them fall,
But when they drop and die
No star is lost at all
From all the star-sown sky.
The toil of all that be
Helps not the primal fault;
It rains into the sea,
And still the sea is salt.

I am, alas, not particularly inspired by the Occupy Wall Street movement,  for sentiments suggested by the poem above and reasons expressed by Thomas Knapp, Gerry Spence, and especially Claire Wolfe, who advises: “Occupy Your Ownself.”

]]>
https://www.peoplevstate.com/?feed=rss2&p=1298 3
Giving the devil his due https://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1290 https://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1290#comments Fri, 07 Oct 2011 00:48:14 +0000 http://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1290 I’ve been reading Clarence Darrow: Attorney for the Damned (2011), by John A. Farrell. Here’s a couple excerpts from the first few chapters which particularly spoke to me.

From Chapter 2 (“Chicago”):

George Schilling was a prominent trade unionist when he encountered Darrow at a gathering of freethinkers. The other speakers had gone too far in mocking the ministry of Jesus Christ, and Darrow “jumped in, and with a ten-minute speech defended the carpenter’s son of Judea with such a sympathetic, persuasive voice that I fell in love with him,” Schilling recalled. “We became fast friends.”

Though Darrow admired Christ’s teachings, he doubted his divinity, and was a regular with Schilling at the Secular Union. . . .

Here, Darrow expressed the deterministic philosophy that would guide him all his life. “The worst of all cruel creeds and of all the bloody wrongs inflicted by the past can be found in the barbarous belief that man is a free moral agent,” he said.

. . .

In August 1887, he wrote a letter to his friends at the Democratic Standard in Ashtabula, recounting a visit with the anarchists in jail.

“They are a good looking intelligent lot of men. At first they were not inclined to talk, but after assuring them that I was something of a crank myself . . . they entered freely into conversation,” Darrow reported. “They imagine that wealth is so strong that it controls legislation and elections and that we can only abolish present evils by wiping out capital and starting over new.

“It is very hard for one who, like me, believes that the injustice of the world can only be remedied through law, and order and system, to understand how intelligent men can believe that the repeal of all laws can better the world; but this is their doctrine.”

. . . “I hope you will not conclude that I am an Anarchist,” he wrote. “I think their doctrines are wild if their eyes are not.”

At the time, Darrow was a member of a single-tax group inspired by author Henry George, who had initially supported the Haymarket defendants but now was running for political office in New York, and modulating his beliefs. He infuriated Darrow and the others by declining to publish the club’s resolution asking for clemency in his organization’s newspaper. Darrow wrote a stinging letter to The Solidarity, a labor publication in New York, accusing George of cowardice.

From Chapter 4 (“Populist”):

Darrow had been shaken by the state’s relentless insistence on killing Prendergast. Now he watched its army and its judges, deployed at the behest of corporations, quell the collective action of American workingmen. The experience left him angry and alienated. The idealist who had said, when he arrived in Chicago, that the “injustice of the world can only be remedied through law, and order and system” began to reconsider.

]]>
https://www.peoplevstate.com/?feed=rss2&p=1290 3
Clarence Darrow on the Single Tax https://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=800 https://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=800#comments Mon, 17 Jan 2011 06:01:26 +0000 http://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=800 Darrow is not as high on my list of all-time favorite people as he is on that of other criminal defense attorneys, but I thought they might not have seen these essays by him and find them of interest:

How to Abolish Unfair Taxation (1913)

The Land Belongs to the People (1916)

]]>
https://www.peoplevstate.com/?feed=rss2&p=800 1