Comments on: Categories https://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1689 fairly undermining public confidence in the administration of justice Sat, 19 Nov 2011 10:48:21 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=5.4.15 By: On Blogrolls and Egotism https://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1689&cpage=1#comment-2311 Sat, 19 Nov 2011 10:48:21 +0000 http://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1689#comment-2311 […] at People v. State, John Kindley announces that, as part of his “intermittent quest for minimalism,” he has […]

]]>
By: John Kindley https://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1689&cpage=1#comment-2297 Wed, 16 Nov 2011 03:06:33 +0000 http://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1689#comment-2297 In reply to John Regan.

I think I agree. Conventions are important. I haven’t wholly lost my old affinity for tradition. It’s just that the prevailing conventions are very bad. If nothing else, by their fruits you shall know them. We have old traditions and old conventions that are more humane, but that are dormant and need to be revived. I think the convention that is most due for over-haul is the persistent and tenacious underlying notion that the State rules by Divine Right. We have much better, more reality-based, conventions in our social history that directly contradict that grossly mistaken notion.

]]>
By: John Regan https://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1689&cpage=1#comment-2296 Wed, 16 Nov 2011 02:05:08 +0000 http://www.peoplevstate.com/?p=1689#comment-2296 I’m not really sure what I was trying to say, exactly, in that post. It’s mostly about the occupy thing, and the way people react to it, which is generally stronger both pro and con than my own reaction.

I’ve begun to think the movement, as it is called, is more significant than it first appeared; and beyond that I just think it requires more thought.

Seeing the contrast between Greenfield and Norm Pattis may be a clue. Greenfield has his good points, but he’s prosaic and with him categories are as rigid as with any establishmentarian; Norm is more lyrical and poetic and far less bound to convention.

It’s important to remember that day to day life would quickly fall apart without well known categories and conventions. If you had to think long and hard about tying your shoes every day things would grind to a halt very quickly and unpleasantly. But the time comes when you have to rethink things. Knowing when that is might be the toughest part.

]]>