Accepting Responsibility
Jamison Koehler has an interesting post up On the Defendant’s Acceptance of Responsibility at Sentencing. I weighed in with a comment, observing:
“Punishing” a defendant for refusing to “accept responsibility” by admitting guilt is completely out of line. It is, however, appropriate to “reward” a defendant who saves the state the trouble and expense of trial by pleading guilty. A guilty-in-fact defendant might internally be genuinely remorseful for what he’s done — but this laudable spiritual attitude doesn’t mean he’s morally bound to accept as a good thing the expiation of his sins the state has in mind for him. The state — quite appropriately — commonly calls into question the sincerity of any remorse expressed by the defendant at sentencing, and argues that the defendant is “sorry” he got caught. We’d all be better off if the “acceptance of responsibility” charade was taken completely off the table.